What employers need to know about the proposed January 2027 changes, and why effective probation is about more than protecting your business.
By Margaret Cawley, Your Life Gym HR Consultancy
Over the years, working across HR, organisational development and leadership, I have seen how much difference good management makes during someone’s first few months in a new role.
Starting a new job is a significant step. Employees want to understand what is expected, feel supported and have a genuine opportunity to succeed. Employers, meanwhile, need confidence that they have made the right recruitment decision.
When probation works well, it gives both sides clarity. When it does not, concerns are left unspoken, reviews are missed and difficult decisions are made at the last minute.
That is why the move towards unfair dismissal protection after six months’ service deserves attention. It should not be a reason to stop recruiting or to become fearful of managing performance. It should be a reason to make probation a meaningful part of how we lead people.
For me, the message is simple: good probation management is not about finding reasons to dismiss someone. It is about creating the conditions for them to succeed, while dealing fairly and promptly with concerns when they arise.
What is changing from 1 January 2027?
Under the Employment Rights Act 2025 reforms described in Acas guidance, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal is due to reduce from two years to six months from 1 January 2027. The statutory compensatory award cap is also due to be removed, although compensation remains linked to the employee’s actual losses and applicable legal principles.
Importantly, the new six-month threshold is expected to apply to employees already in post who have reached that length of service when the change takes effect. Employers should also pay attention to transitional provisions and the effective date of termination, particularly where notice starts in December and ends in January.
The practical implication is that employers will have a much shorter period in which to identify concerns, offer support, assess progress and make informed decisions.
But I would encourage businesses not to view this simply as a legal deadline. A well-run probation process should already be helping people settle into their roles, understand expectations and receive regular feedback.
Probation is not a period without employment rights
One misconception I still come across is that an employer can dismiss someone during probation without needing to think about fairness or legal risk.
That has never been a safe assumption. Protections against discrimination and certain automatically unfair reasons for dismissal can apply from the beginning of employment, regardless of how long someone has worked for you.
Pregnancy and maternity, whistleblowing, trade union activities, health and safety concerns and asserting certain statutory rights are among the areas where employers need particular care.
Probation is an opportunity to assess suitability, but it does not remove the need for fair, consistent and evidence-based management.
The notice period trap: why timing matters
There is also a technical point that smaller employers can easily overlook: the date you communicate a dismissal is not always the date used to calculate qualifying service.
For ordinary unfair dismissal eligibility, statutory minimum notice can affect the calculation of the effective date of termination in certain circumstances. An employee dismissed just short of six months may therefore still reach the threshold for bringing a claim.
For example, an employee with more than a month’s service will generally be entitled to at least one week’s statutory notice, unless an exception applies. Simply paying in lieu of notice or making a rushed decision in the final few days may not achieve what the employer assumes.
This is exactly why I advise managers to avoid leaving probation decisions until the last week. Review progress early, address concerns as they arise and obtain appropriate advice before acting on a borderline case.
Why I believe probation needs to be a conversation, not a tick-box exercise
I have seen probation forms completed at the end of a review period when very little meaningful feedback has taken place beforehand. The employee believes everything is going well, while the manager has been quietly building a list of concerns.
That is neither good leadership nor good people management.
Employees deserve to know where they stand. If performance or behaviour is not meeting expectations, explain the gap, agree what improvement looks like and provide reasonable support. Managers also need to be honest about whether the expectations were clear and whether the employee had the training and resources to deliver.
A probation period can be longer or shorter than six months, depending on the role and the contract. However, extending probation does not postpone statutory unfair dismissal rights once the qualifying service requirement has been met.
The focus therefore needs to be on the quality and timing of your management process, not just the date written into the contract.
Seven practical steps to strengthen your probation process
1. Set out the probation arrangements from day one
Make sure the employee receives clear written particulars covering any probation period and its conditions. Explain how reviews work, what standards apply and how decisions will be made.
2. Agree clear and realistic expectations
In the first week, discuss the role, priorities, behaviours and what success looks like. A small number of meaningful objectives is often more useful than a long list nobody revisits.
3. Schedule reviews before they become urgent
Build regular one-to-one conversations into the diary, for example at one, three and five months. Keep brief records, share feedback and agree next steps. Do not rely on a single meeting at the end.
4. Address concerns early and support improvement
If something is not working, be specific. Explain what needs to change, give examples, ask what support is needed and agree a sensible review date. Consider training, coaching and reasonable adjustments where relevant.
5. Make decisions with enough time for a fair process
Review the employee’s progress well ahead of the six-month point. Allow time to consider the evidence, listen to their response, take advice and account for contractual and statutory notice.
6. Manage extensions properly
Where an extension is appropriate and permitted, confirm the reasons, objectives, support and revised end date in writing. Remember that an extension does not stop statutory rights arising at six months.
7. Handle dismissal fairly when it is necessary
Sometimes, despite support, a role is not the right fit. If dismissal is being considered, use a fair process, understand the reason, listen to the employee, check notice and confirm the decision in writing. Consider an appeal and the applicable Acas guidance.
The Acas Code and the importance of a fair process
Where conduct or performance issues lead towards formal action, employers should consider the Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures and whether it applies to the circumstances.
That generally means establishing the facts, setting out concerns clearly, giving the employee an opportunity to respond, respecting accompaniment rights where applicable, communicating decisions and providing an appeal route.
An employment tribunal may adjust relevant awards by up to 25% where there has been an unreasonable failure to follow the Code. Not every probation-related decision falls within the Code in exactly the same way, so employers should seek advice on the specific facts rather than assume one process fits every situation.
The best protection is not paperwork created after a problem. It is evidence of consistent, fair management throughout the employee’s time with you.
Managers need support too
Many probation issues are not caused by a lack of policy. They arise because managers are busy, uncomfortable giving difficult feedback or unsure how to document concerns.
That is why I believe manager development is just as important as reviewing your contracts and templates.
Give managers practical tools: a simple review form, guidance on having constructive conversations, clear escalation routes and access to HR advice when decisions become difficult.
Good managers should not have to guess how to do the right thing.
Frequently asked questions
Will the six-month rule apply to employees already working for us?
The announced reform is intended to cover existing employees who have at least six months’ qualifying service when the new rule takes effect. Review your workforce and check the final commencement and transitional provisions.
Can we still dismiss someone during probation?
Yes, but probation does not remove employment rights. Decisions should be supported by a fair reason, appropriate process, evidence and correct notice.
Does a nine-month probation period delay unfair dismissal protection?
No. Contractual probation and the statutory qualifying period are separate things.
What if notice takes someone beyond six months?
The effective date of termination and statutory notice rules can affect qualifying service. This is particularly important close to the six-month threshold; seek advice before relying on a precise cut-off date.
Do we need a probation policy?
There is no general legal requirement to operate probation, but a clear written process helps managers act consistently and employees understand expectations.
My message to employers: make probation work for people and the business
When I think about these changes, I do not see a reason to become defensive about hiring. I see an opportunity to strengthen everyday management.
If someone is struggling, early and honest feedback gives them a fair chance to improve. If a decision ultimately has to be made, good records and a thoughtful process help the employer explain it clearly.
For smaller businesses, this does not need to mean complicated systems or endless forms. It means having expectations, conversations and decisions that are timely, consistent and fair.
Good HR is not just about reducing risk. It is about helping people and businesses succeed together.
How Your Life Gym HR Consultancy can support your business
At Your Life Gym HR Consultancy, I bring a practical, people-centred approach to HR, organisational development and leadership. I understand that smaller businesses need processes that managers can actually use, not just documents that sit in a folder.
Through our Essential HR support, I can help with probation policies, contracts and handbooks, review templates, manager training, performance management and employee relations advice when difficult decisions arise.
If you are unsure whether your probation process is ready for the 2027 changes, let’s have a conversation. We can look at what is working, where the risks are and the practical steps to take next.
Because good people decisions are good business decisions.
Your Life. Your Business. Your People.
This article is for general information and is not legal advice. The proposed commencement dates, transitional provisions and Acas guidance should be checked against the latest official publications before action is taken.
Sources and further guidance
- Acas — Employment Rights Act changes
- Acas — Probation periods
- Acas — Unfair dismissal
- Acas — Notice periods when dismissing
- Employment Rights Act 1996, section 97
- Acas — Disciplinary and grievance Code of Practice
- GOV.UK — Written statement of employment particulars
- Employment Rights Act 2025 — legislation
