A practical guide to the conversations that help managers become more effective leaders.
By Margaret Cawley, Your Life Gym Leadership & Team Development
What do managers actually bring to leadership coaching?
It is rarely just one thing. A manager might arrive wanting to feel more confident in difficult conversations, only to discover that the real challenge is setting expectations. Another might want to improve delegation, but underneath that is a fear of losing control. This is why I see leadership coaching as more than a conversation about techniques. It is an opportunity to understand the behaviours, assumptions and pressures shaping how someone leads.
The leadership coaching topics I see most often include delegation, feedback, difficult conversations, strategy, influence, change, trust, performance, priorities and wellbeing. The starting point will depend on the individual, their team and what the business needs. Below, I have included a question for each topic that can help turn reflection into action.
Why managers need space to develop
Many people become managers because they are good at their job, not because they have been prepared to lead others. The Chartered Management Institute’s 2023 Better Management report found that 82% of people entering management had received no formal management and leadership training. It describes this group as “accidental managers”. That does not mean they cannot lead well. It means organisations need to take management development seriously.
Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace 2026 also reported a decline in global manager engagement, from 27% to 22% in 2025. It is a reminder that we cannot keep asking managers to support everyone else without giving them support themselves. Coaching can provide that space, alongside good training, clear expectations and organisational support.
The 10 leadership coaching topics
1. Delegation and letting go
“It would be quicker if I did it myself.”
The shift from expert to manager can be uncomfortable. If you have always been the person who gets things done, handing over responsibility can feel like a risk. We work on clarifying the outcome, agreeing boundaries and allowing others to take ownership without stepping in at the first sign of a different approach.
A coaching question: : What are you holding on to that someone else needs the opportunity to learn?
2. Giving feedback that helps people grow
“I have told them, but nothing has changed.”
Feedback needs to be clear, timely and two-way. We explore what was actually said, whether expectations were understood and how to create a conversation rather than deliver a verdict. Praise deserves the same attention as corrective feedback.
A coaching question: : If you were receiving this feedback, would you know exactly what to continue or change?
3. Difficult conversations
“I know I need to address it, but I keep putting it off.”
Whether it is underperformance, behaviour or tension between colleagues, avoidance rarely makes a problem easier. Coaching gives managers the chance to prepare, test their assumptions and practise a respectful, direct approach. The CIPD identifies handling conflict as one area where coaching can support technically capable managers.
A coaching question: : What is the impact of not having this conversation, on you, the individual and the team?
4. Thinking more strategically
“I spend the whole week reacting.”
As responsibilities grow, managers need to lift their eyes beyond the immediate task. We look at priorities, competing demands and the difference between urgent activity and meaningful progress. Strategic thinking is not reserved for directors; it begins with understanding what matters most.
A coaching question: : Which decision are you avoiding because you are too busy managing today?
5. Influencing without authority
“I need people on board, but they do not report to me.”
Cross-functional work demands influence rather than instruction. Coaching can help managers see an issue from another stakeholder’s perspective, build relationships and make a stronger case without becoming overly accommodating.
A coaching question: : What matters most to the person you are trying to influence?
6. Leading through change
“My team wants answers I do not have yet.”
Change can bring uncertainty for the manager as well as the team. We focus on communicating what is known, being honest about what is not, listening to concerns and helping people understand what remains within their control. The CIPD recognises supporting people through change as a use of coaching.
A coaching question: : What can you communicate clearly today, even while some answers are still emerging?
7. Building trust and psychological safety
“Nobody challenges me in meetings.”
Silence is not always agreement. A manager’s response to questions, mistakes and disagreement shapes whether people feel safe to speak up. Google’s Project Aristotle identified psychological safety as an important dynamic in effective teams. We explore the small, everyday behaviours that build or weaken trust.
A coaching question: : When someone last disagreed with you, how did you respond?
8. Managing performance fairly
“I have one person carrying the workload and another falling behind.”
Performance management is not about waiting for a formal process. It begins with clear goals, regular conversations, appropriate support and fair accountability. Coaching helps managers distinguish between capability, clarity, motivation and obstacles beyond the individual’s control.
A coaching question: : Have you made your expectations clear enough that the person could describe success in their own words?
9. Time, priorities and energy
“I am in meetings all day and working in the evening.”
When every request feels important, boundaries disappear. We review how the manager spends their time, what only they can do, and where habits such as over-availability or perfectionism are getting in the way.
A coaching question: : What would happen if you stopped attending one meeting that no longer needs you?
10. Wellbeing: supporting others without neglecting yourself
“I am worried about my team, but I am exhausted too.”
Managers have a role in noticing workload pressures and creating supportive working conditions, but they are not expected to be therapists. The HSE’s Management Standards highlight the importance of demands, control, support, relationships, role and change. Coaching can help a manager reflect on boundaries and supportive leadership; where clinical or therapeutic help is needed, a different professional may be appropriate.
A coaching question: : What support would you encourage a team member to seek if they were feeling as you do?
An emerging topic: leading teams through AI
Managers are increasingly being asked to introduce AI tools while their teams are still deciding what those tools mean for their work. The challenge is not simply technical. It is about trust, communication, confidence and helping people experiment responsibly. Coaching can help a leader make space for questions, identify useful applications and avoid promising certainty where none exists.
A coaching question: : How will you create an environment where people can test new tools, share concerns and learn from mistakes?
Different stages of leadership, different conversations
For a first-time manager, the focus may be on delegation, feedback and moving from colleague to leader. For an experienced manager, influence, team performance and change often become more prominent. Senior leaders may bring questions about culture, strategic choices and leading through other leaders. There is no fixed progression. A very experienced leader can still find a difficult conversation challenging.
Where should you start?
I encourage managers to start with the challenge that is having the greatest impact, not the one that sounds most impressive. Look for recurring patterns. Gather feedback from your team, peers and line manager. Choose one or two outcomes you want to change over the next few months, and agree how you will recognise progress. A 360-degree feedback exercise can provide useful perspectives, but it works best when people feel safe to be honest and the feedback leads to action.
What makes leadership coaching effective?
Coaching is not a substitute for good management systems, training or adequate resources. The CIPD cautions that coaching is not a universal solution. In my experience, the strongest programmes combine clear goals, honest feedback, opportunities to practise between sessions and enough trust for the manager to talk openly. Sometimes the most useful moment is when someone realises that the problem they brought is not quite the problem they need to solve.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most common leadership coaching topics?
Delegation, feedback, difficult conversations, strategic thinking, influence, change, trust, performance, priorities and wellbeing are common starting points. The right topic depends on the manager and the situation.
How is leadership coaching different from training?
Training builds shared knowledge and skills. Coaching focuses on an individual’s real situations, helping them reflect, make choices and apply what they learn. They are often most effective together.
Is leadership coaching only for senior managers?
No. New managers can benefit from coaching before unhelpful habits become established, while experienced and senior leaders often use it to work through more complex decisions and relationships.
How do you measure progress?
Agree two or three observable goals at the outset. Review behavioural changes, feedback and relevant team outcomes. A 360-degree review may help, but avoid assuming that changes in retention or engagement are caused by coaching alone.
How we can help
At Your Life Gym, our leadership coaching supports new managers, experienced leaders and leadership teams in London and online. Drawing on more than 20 years in HR, organisational development and leadership development, I combine practical understanding of the workplace with coaching that encourages reflection, accountability and meaningful behaviour change. Our programmes can include 360-degree feedback at no additional cost, alongside one-to-one or group coaching.
If you are developing your managers or facing a leadership challenge yourself, book a discovery call and we can talk about what support would make the biggest difference.
Related reading
- First-time manager? A practical 90-day plan
- 360 feedback questions: 33 examples by competency
- The 5 stages of team development, and how to move your team forward
This article provides general leadership development information, not individual professional or clinical advice.

